![]()
Revelation and the Seven
Congregations
By Rosh Paqid Adon Hillel ben David
Paqid Adon Micah ben Hillel, &
Paqid Adon Poriel ben Avraham
![]()
![]()
FOREWORD
By: Hakham Dr.
Yosef ben Haggai
Many tomes have been published offering a commentary on the Book of the Apocalypse of Yochanan (John) Chapters 1:1 – 3:22 dealing with seven symbolic Nazarean Jewish congregations in Asia Minor. Some of these tomes are big, others small, some are of substance, others are just inconsequential and money making enterprises. None to this day, however to my knowledge have dealt with this rich mystical passage with Jewish eyes. In fact, one of the problems that characterize all the commentators so far is that they are limited by their theological straightjackets of their pagan liturgical calendar and festivals, as well as an extreme ignorance of the Jewish Festivals and how the Jewish people understand and use their Scriptures.
Whilst this essay does not claim to be a profound scholarly exegesis of the verses in question, it surely does offer any student of the Bible a bold perspective by which to understand this extremely complex portion of this great Jewish mystical book. Some of its great pearls of wisdom are only basically explored and other important secrets are just brought to the surface in the form of mere allusion.
Before one enters to examine this profound Jewish mystical book, one needs to understand that Jewish mystics speak and write using symbolical language to describe cosmic realities that affect all. One also needs to have a good grasp of the Jewish liturgical year and its sacred festivals, including the weekly Sabbath. Lastly one needs to understand the very reality which is turned into a symbol in order to better comprehend that symbol.
Professor Walter J. Veith[1] aptly describes the reason why these seven congregations were symbolized in order to use these as the medium in which a very special message from HaShem is conveyed to all Nazareans wherever they be and at whatever period in history they might live. He states:
The seven congregations to which the seven letters were addressed were those of Ephesus, Smyrna, Pergamos, Thyatira, Sardis, Philadelphia and Laodicea. These cities stood along one of the ancient postal Roman roads of that day, and, beginning at Ephesus, would have been visited in the order in which they are named. The distance between them is about 50-60 kilometers; a full day's journey, on foot.
Also, when the Roman Emperor sent out governors each year to outlying provinces, these would make the circuit, stopping in certain towns to hear cases and grievances. The governor who oversaw Asia Minor would land in Ephesus, continue to Smyrna, then Pergamum, etc. through all of the seven congregations mentioned in the book of the Apocalypse.
If we take these congregations as symbolic of a Divine circuit in definite period of time with seven stopovers, then we can see that these are types of seven human spiritual conditions for which HaShem offers the Jewish observant soul seven clinics, or seven respite centers, i.e. seven festivals, along his/her pilgrimage throughout the circuit of the year, in which to receive healing and nourishment for the soul. Another such Divine circuit in time is presented to us by the Septennial readings of Scriptures concluding with a Sabbatical year. Each of these Divine circuits and its seven recharging stopovers are also intimately related to the seven ministries or gifts of the Spirit to any Nazarean Jewish congregation[2].
This understanding, of course, has more to do with bringing heaven down to earth, and making presently fallen and unjust realities conform to heavenly realities. The idea that these seven congregations represent seven points in Christian history[3] is therefore totally erroneous, presenting a flight from reality, and a rejection of the five-fold divine task given to man, “to be fruitful, to multiply, to replenish the earth, to subdue it, and to have dominion over it through the observance of HaShem’s commandments.”[4]
One of course, needs to abide by the critical counsel of Hakham Shaul (Apostle Paul) given in his Epistle to the Romans:
“What then is the advantage of being a Jew? Or what is the benefit of circumcision? Much in every way! For indeed first and foremost, that they [the Jewish people] were entrusted with the oracles of HaShem.” - Romans 3:1-2
Any other approach that is not based on the “oracles” (i.e. Jewish oral traditions) of interpreting sacred writings is absolutely doomed to failure, and will be found lacking the authenticity, intellectual and spiritual satisfaction of those who believe in HaShem’s Word and observe the commandments of HaShem.
The book of Revelation is an interesting one.
It’s the last book in the Nazarean Codicil, making it the last book in many
bibles. The last word in the book is ‘Amen’, which has a sort of inspirational
feeling to it, which is further accentuated by its aforementioned position
within the Good Book.
However, to most people the book is quite
incomprehensible. That’s largely because it is suppose to be. Revelation was
written at the Sod level of Jewish
hermeneutics, which is the deepest and most complex of the four levels. It is, what you might call, the strongest
form of encryption you’ll find in Jewish literature. This is either really
troublesome or really exciting depending on how you look at it.
So then, depending on your point of view, this
study will be troublesome or exciting as well, because the goal of this study
is to begin to uncover the rich garden of secrets this
book contains; makes me sprout a green thumb just thinking about it.
However, we will limit our scope to
understanding what relationship Revelation has to the biblical festivals and
the Shmita (Triennial / Septennial) Torah-reading
cycle. With this we will fence in our garden.
We have previously learned that whenever you
see a number of items, like seven festival Sabbaths,
you can be assured that it will teach you about another group of seven items, like the seven congregations.
In this paper we will be looking to use this technique to understand the book of
Revelation. We started by building tables which show the relationships between
the congregations and the festival Sabbaths.
As we studied the connections between the seven
congregations and the seven festivals, we found that there seems to be a
correlation only with the Nisan cycle of the triennial or Shmita
Torah reading cycle. This cycle starts in Nisan
and ends, three and a half years later, in Tishri.
Therefore, our tables reflect the festival Sabbaths as starting in Nisan.
Additionally, the festivals are normally viewed as starting with Pesach, in Nisan. Let’s look at the connections between the festivals and the seven congregations.
So first we are introduced to the deep
symbolism of the Menorah. It says:
Revelation 1:4-20 Yochanan (John) to the seven congregations that are in
...
What you do see, write in a scroll, and send to the seven congregations that are in
...
I saw seven golden lamp-stands, and in
the midst of the seven lamp-stands, one like to a son of man
...
having in his right hand seven stars
...
the secret of the seven stars that you
have seen upon my right hand, and the seven golden lamp-stands: the seven
stars are prophets of the seven congregations, and the seven lamp-stands that you
have seen are seven congregations.
Rule 1 of Sod: Ignore
numbers at your own peril. Rule 2 of Sod: When something is repeated, that
means it’s important.
We have three apparent
sets of seven. We have seven congregations, stars, and lamp-stands. They are clearly being planted near each other
in this garden for a reason. As it says in the Torah:
Devarim (Deuteronomy) 22:9 You shall not sow your vineyard with two
[different] kinds of seed.
So, in our garden, seeds planted together are
not different, but are in fact the same. But what are we to learn from this
juxtaposition of symbols? Let us dig deeper.
In the next two
chapters, Revelation deals mainly with the sins of each of the above seven congregations. Those congregations and their sins are as
follows:
So
now we must analyze these and unearth their hidden meanings. Of course, as we
said earlier, we’ve limited our scope and thereby biased ourselves towards
understanding Revelation’s relationship to the biblical festivals and the years
in the Shmita Torah-reading cycle.
It just so happens that there are seven festival Sabbaths and
seven years in a Shmita Torah-reading cycle. I wonder if there is any relationship
between these. To answer this question, we must first list the festivals. They
are:
If
you are familiar with the festivals, you may have thought that the list would
be like so:
However,
it will become apparent later on why that list does not fit with the seven congregations and their sins.
However, the mindful reader will note the symmetry of the first list.
Our
hypothesis is that the festivals act like a medicine of sorts. Each festival
enacts a tikkun, a reparation, of the sins each of these communities sinned. Of
course, even today we commit these sins, and so we require regular treatment
via the festivals to atone for those sins.
To be
a medicine, the festivals must specifically target the source of the sins,
reversing their effects. So then, the next thing we must do is test our
hypothesis and observe whether there is some truth to it. In the process, we'll
be able to test whether we are mingling unlike seeds
together with this hypothesis.
The book of Revelation opens with the words: The Revelation of Yeshua HaMashiach. This meshes perfectly with Shemot (Exodus) 20:1 as it introduces the revelation of the Torah: And HaShem spoke all these words, saying… We can also see that this accords with Yochanan (John) 1:1 where the mystical term used to describe Yeshua is The Word. The Word is also a connection to the Torah.
Each of the seven communities is introduced with a salutation to the Angel of the Congregation. This is no accident. The Angel of the Congregation was the public minister of the synagogue. He was responsible for public prayer, or appointing those who read from the Torah, and he sometimes preached if there were no others to discharge this office. This man did not read the Torah publicly, but, every Shabbat (Sabbath) he called out seven of the synagogue (on other days fewer) whom he judged fit to read. He stood by those that read and carefully made sure that they read correctly. He would correct them if they made an error. It is for this reason that he was also called an ‘overseer’. Thus, if HaShem has a message for a congregation He would entrust it to this man in order to ensure that it was read in the synagogue.
Each of the seven communities were in a trade route which we shall call a milk run. In the same way, we encounter each of the seven festivals as we trace a path through the year. The following chart illustrates this concept:
First
is the sin of
Revelation
2:1-7 1 `To the prophet
of the Ephesian congregation write: These things says he who is holding the seven stars in his right
hand, who is walking in the midst of the seven lamp-stands--the golden: 2
I have known your works, and thy labor, and your endurance, and that you
art not able to bear evil ones, and that you have
tried those saying themselves to be shliachim (apostles) and are not, and have
found them liars, 3 and you did bear, and have endurance, and
because of my name have toiled, and have not been weary. 4 `But I
have against you: That your first love you did leave! 5 remember,
then, whence you have fallen, and reform, and the first works do; and if not, I
come to you quickly, and will remove you lamp-stand from its place--if you may
not reform; 6 but this you have, that you do hate the works of the
Nicolaitans, that I also hate. 7 He who is having an ear--let
him hear what the Spirit says to the congregations: To him who is overcoming--I will give to him
to eat of the tree of life
that is in the midst of the pardes (paradise)
of HaShem.
The sin here is specifically that we have “left our first
love”. But what does it mean, symbolically, to leave one's first love?
I
suppose it would be even better to first ask, why would one leave his or her
first love? Bordom? Finding fault with him or her? Perhaps one found something
else one loves even more? Any one of these seems like a reasonably good guess.
Perhaps
then, the symbolism is that our love changes based on our perception of HaShem.
That is, we no longer see Him as our first love and lose the connection that
comes with that perception of Him.
If
so, which festival would this allude to then? It
certainly isn’t Yom HaKippurim, the tone of voice isn’t right for
that festival; Yom HaKippurim is a time of judgment and we don't have any
indication that this passage relates to judgment. The same is true, in part,
for Yom
Teruah.
Pesach appears to be a good fit. On Pesach we prepare
ahead of time by searching our house for leaven[5]
and purging it; it is a time of introspection whereby we reveal our most hidden
inclinations and faults. Later, we recall the miracles
that HaShem did when He took us out of Egypt, redeeming His people from the harsh, laborious
slavery which they endured for over 200 years. We recapture the passion that we
had at that time for our Savior and we rekindle our love for Him.
Support
for this argument can be found in the Tanakh[6]
where it states:
Yiremeyahu
(Jeremiah) 2:2 Go and cry in the ears of Jerusalem,
saying, Thus says HaShem; I remember you, the kindness of your youth, the love
of your espousals, when you went after me in the
wilderness, in a land that was not sown.
The community at
So
the first day of Pesach seems to naturally sprout
from this passage from Revelation where we followed HaShem into the wilderness during
Pesach. This was the time of our first love. Thus the congregations at
So, how do we return to our first love? How do
we return to HaShem? The answer is the best kept secret of the Jews. Yeshua gave us the
answer in a very succinct manner. He said, “If you love me, keep my commands” [7].
Thus we learn that we need to observe Pesach according to the halacha. We need to clean the leaven out of our houses,
celebrate the seder, and eat matza.[8]
Leaven is a symbol of the yetzer hara[9],
the evil inclination. We took on the yetzer hara when Adam and Chava ate from
the tree of the knowledge of good and evil. It was
the result of eating of the tree of doubt. The
yetzer hara is what caused us to move away from HaShem and pretend that we
could hide from Him. By eliminating the yetzer hara, we return to our state
before Adam’s sin. We can return to our first love, we
return to HaShem.
So, how does the seder contribute to the
tikkun? The main focus of the seder are the miracles. What was the purpose of
the miracles? Chazal, our Sages, teach the miracles were designed to teach the
Egyptians that HaShem is HaShem. Now surely if it convinced the skeptics; what
do you suppose would be the effect on those who already believed? The best way
to relate to this, is to imagine the state of a man who falls over a cliff and
is miraculously saved by being levitated back to the top of the cliff. Even a
confirmed skeptic would become religious after an experience
like that. Now, imagine that you experienced the mighty miracles that HaShem
sent as plagues on the Egyptians. I suspect that
this would cause us to return to our first love.
Finally, Pesach would not be Pesach without
matza. Matza is the food we ate on that first Pesach
because the bread did not have time to rise, as we learn from the haggada[10].
Matza symbolizes redemption according to Maharal[11].
The time of our redemption was the time of our following HaShem into the
wilderness. It was the time when we followed our first love. When we eat matza
we renew the redemptive relationship we had with HaShem when we followed Him
into the wilderness.
Next
is
Revelation
2:8-11 8 `And to the
prophet of the congregation of the Smyrneans write: These things says the First
and the Last, who did become dead and did live; 9 I have known your
works, and tribulation, and poverty--yet you art rich--and the evil-speaking of
those saying themselves to be Jews, and are not, but are a synagogue of the Adversary. 10 `Be not
afraid of the things that you art about to suffer; lo, the devil is about
to cast of you to prison, that you may be tried, and you shall have tribulation
ten days; become you faithful unto death, and I will
give to you the crown of the life. 11 He who is having an ear--let him hear what the Spirit says to the congregations: He who is overcoming may not be injured of the second death.
Initially,
the sin is not obvious, but with close examination we can see there is indeed a
sin. The sin of the community at
“Wait”,
you may say, “how can fear be a sin?! That’s ridiculous.” It may sound that
way, but the fear here is a paralyzing fear that keeps one from doing what is
correct. If one believes in the sovereignty of HaShem
and believes that He is the source of everything, especially suffering, then
one would never have such a fear. So then the fear here reveals that
You
may say to me, “But it doesn’t say that HaShem will bring suffering, but rather
the Devil will!” I would then respond, “And who made the Devil?” Everything is
from HaShem, and anybody that believes otherwise is committing the sin spoken
of here.
If we
are to correlate this congregation and sin to a festival
that acts as a tikkun, a reparation, of that sin, then the seventh day of Pesach would fit well. We know from a previous
study that the passage of the Israelites through the Yam Suf (
The Egyptians were pursuing us from behind while the Yam Suf blocked our forward movement. We were being squeezed one last time. Suddenly the birth canal opened with the splitting of the Yam Suf. As we hurried down that canal, the Egyptians pursued us with the intent to bring us back to slavery after having their way with us first. This was a death experience. Remember the fear that the Israelites felt as they were waiting to cross the Yam Suf?
Shemoth
(exodus) (Exodus)
This
shows us that the fear in
Consider also that when we crossed the Yam Suf we were being baptized into Moshe:
1
Corinthians 10:1-2 Moreover, brethren, I would not that ye should be
ignorant, how that all our fathers were under the
cloud, and all passed through the sea; 2 And were
all baptized unto Moses in the cloud and in the sea;
Baptism is a death experience. It symbolizes our death and resurrection. As we remember the tribulations of the seventh day of Pesach, we realize that HaShem is taking care of us and that our current tribulation will also turn out HaShem’s way. His mighty hand saved us then, and His mighty hand will save us now. As we celebrate this festival Shabbat, we see that the tikkun for our fears is the subject of our Torah studies and the our prayers.
Shemoth
(exodus) (Exodus) 14:10-14 10 And when Pharaoh drew near, the
children of Yisrael lifted up their eyes, and, behold,
the Egyptians were marching after them; and they were sore afraid; and the
children of Yisrael cried out unto HaShem. 11 And they said unto Moses:
'Because there were no graves in
By
recalling the testing at the Yam Suf and by acknowledging HaShem’s sovereignty
such that we no longer fear the tribulation, we repair the sin
that they sinned at the Yam Suf (
Bereans
(Hebrews) 4:1-13 Let us therefore fear, lest, a promise being left
us of entering into his rest, any of you should seem
to come short of it. 2 For unto us was the Masorah
(gospel) preached, as well as unto them: but the word preached did not profit
them, not being mixed with faithful obedience in them that heard it. 3 For we
which have faithfully obeyed do enter into rest, as he said, As I have sworn in
my wrath, if they shall enter into my rest: although the works were finished
from the foundation of the world. 4 For he spoke in a certain place of the seventh day on this wise, And HaShem
did rest the seventh day from all his works. 5 And in this place again, If they
shall enter into my rest. 6 Seeing therefore it remains that some must enter
therein, and they to whom it was first preached entered not in because they had
not faithfully obeyed: 7 Again, he limits a certain day, saying in David, To
day, after so long a time; as it is said, To day if you
will hear his voice, harden not your hearts. 8 For if Yehoshua had given them
rest, then would he not afterward have spoken of another day. 9 There remains
therefore a rest to the people of HaShem. 10 For he that is entered into his
rest, he also hath ceased from his own works, as HaShem did from his. 11
Let us labor therefore to enter into that rest, lest any man fall after the
same example of unbelief. 12 For the word of HaShem is quick, and powerful,
and sharper than any two-edged sword, piercing even to the dividing asunder of
soul and spirit, and of the joints and marrow, and is a discerner of the thoughts
and intents of the heart. 13 Neither is there any creature that is not manifest
in his sight: but all things are naked and opened unto the eyes of him with
whom we have to do.
Thus,
we see that the tribulation at
The
next two congregations are interesting ones to look
at. Let us begin by looking at the congregation of
Pergamos:
Revelation
2:12-15 12 And to the prophet of the congregation in Pergamos
write; These things says he which hath the sharp sword with two
edges; 13 I know your works, and where you dwell, [even] where Satan's seat
[is]: and you hold fast my name, and hast not denied my faith, even in those
days wherein Antipas [was] my faithful martyr, who was slain among you, where
Satan dwell. 14 But I have a few things against thee, because you
hast there them that hold the doctrine of Balaam, who taught Balaq to cast a stumbling block before the children of Yisrael, to eat things sacrificed unto
idols, and to commit fornication. 15 So you also have them that hold the doctrine
of the Nicolaitans, which thing I hate.
Shavuot was the time
of the receiving of the Torah. This was the time when we were able to
understand the quality of our relationship with HaShem. This provides the
perfect tikkun to the sin of the congregations at
Pergamos which had descended into idolatry and fornication. When we reflect of
the relationship and intimacy with HaShem, as we
had at Sinai, we see the correction to following after a relationship and
intimacy with false gods.
Yiremeyahu (Jeremiah) 3:8 And I saw, when for all the causes whereby backsliding Israel committed
adultery I had put her away, and given her a bill of divorce; yet her
treacherous sister Judah feared not, but went and played the harlot also.
The primary mitzvot for Shavuot is the tikkun leil Shavuot (studying all night) and hearing the Ten Commandments. By immersing ourselves in the Torah the night before Shavuot, we replace our idolatry with attachment to HaShem as we remember this day of our betrothal. We remember the awe we had as we heard the giving of the Ten Commandments, our betrothal gift. This is the tikkun for idolatry.
When we reflect of the relationship and intimacy with HaShem, as we had at Sinai, we see
the correction to following after a relationship and intimacy with false gods.
The community
at Pergamos is the third to be named in the list of the seven congregations
mentioned. Next in the list after the seventh day
festival sabbath of Pesach comes Shavuot (Pentecost
– the Feast of Weeks). It was on Shavuot, the sixth of
the month of Sivan, that Moshe Rabbenu (Moses) received the Torah from
Sinai, who then transmitted it to Yehoshua ben Nun (Joshua);[12]
this was the same torah that the children of Israel received. On Shavuot, one
of the events that happened forty days after this date
was the sin of the golden calf; in other words,
idolatry. Also, the first few commandments of the Ten Commandments deals
with serving HaShem and not created things, so this would seem a perfect fit
with Pergamos.
The Nicolaitans[13]
were known to follow after the example of Balaam. As their name connotes, they
exacted authority over the people and cast
stumbling blocks before them. The Nicolaitans prodded and incited the people of
Yisrael to idolatry like the Erev Rav, the mixed multitude (which Onkelos
designates as strangers, in his
Targum), which came out of Egypt with the
Israelites.
Thus, the Tikkun for the problem at Pergamos is to attach and cleave ourselves back to HaShem, the leaders of the communities and study Torah. This is the tikkun for adultery / idolatry we experience during Shavuot [as Pergamos].
Let us move on to the next community, Thyatira.
Revelation
2:18-20 18 And
unto the prophet of the community in Thyatira write;
These things says the Son of HaShem, who has his eyes like unto a flame of fire, and his feet [are] like fine
brass; 19 I know your works, and tzedakah
(charity/generosity), and Avodah (service/worship), and emunah (faithful
obedience), and your patience, and your works; and the last [to be] more than
the first. 20 Notwithstanding I have a few things against your,
because you suffer that woman Jezebe[14]l,
which call herself a prophetess, to teach and to
seduce my servants to commit fornication, and to
eat things sacrificed unto idols.
Here we find something similar to
the trouble we find in Pergamos. Why is it that both of these communities have
a few sins that are keeping them from complete approval? And why are both their
sins, idolatry (fornication) and breaking the laws of kashrut (eating things sacrificed to idols), similar to the
other? We know that there are seven congregations, and
with a careful look into the book of Revelation, even a child will be able to
understand that the events mentioned in the book will be executed within a cycle of seven years.
Thus far, the only differences that
we find with these two communities is that the first, Pergamos, has a giving
role since they hold to the teaching of Balaam (Balaq)
who is male; whilst Thyatira holds a receiving role, a female quality, since
they suffer the teaching of Jezebel. The other is
that some in Pergamos hold to the teaching of the Nicolaitans.
In Judaism, once we hear about a
“seven-year-cycle” we immediately recall to mind the Shmita cycle.
This cycle, as most know it, deals with farming
cycles (and farming cycles are based on the seasons),
however, in the days of the Master of Nazareth, the
Torah was read twice (two, three-and-a-half year reading
cycles) in a Sabbatical
cycle of seven years.
The sins of Thyatira:
1)
Allow that
woman Jezebel (whore of Baal) to teach.
2)
A woman
establishes herself as the leader of the community.
3)
Seduces
the slaves causing them to go astray.
4a) Sexual immorality
4b) Intermarriage
4c) Idolatry/Apostasy
5a) Eat foods
to Idols
5b) Celebrate pagan
festivals instead of HaShem's festivals
5c) Abandon laws of Kashrut
Let us take a look at Jezebel[15]:
Strongs concordance, number 348, [16] describes her name as meaning Chaste which comes from Iy, meaning idea of a query, and Zebul, meaning a dwelling place or residence. Jewish tradition, however, renders the meaning of this name, not exalted, based on the vowels used.
“But it is highly
unlikely her parents would have given her such a name. Read with different
vowels it can be understood as meaning "Where is the Prince?" ('ay
zebul in Hebrew). In fact, early Syrian inscriptions
from
The first sin of Thyatira is that they allowed this Jezebel, a non-Jewish woman, to marry one of their leaders (probably the shliach tzibbur himself). They also condoned her teaching the community. We find this explained in 1 Melachim (Kings) 16:31, where Yirmeyahu (Jeremiah) tells us that Jezebel was a Phoenician princess, daughter of Ithobaal I, the King of Tyre, and married King Ahab when he took the throne of the Northern Tribes.
2 Melachim (kings) tells us that when Jezebel was murdered, her body was left for dogs to consume in a vineyard; only her head, hands and legs were spared by the dogs.
This led to the second error the community of Thyatira committed in which they allowed Jezebel to become the Angel of the Congregation. In Jewish law, there is no role of Queen, in this case, she was the Angel of the Congregation. Though, there are certain laws which pertain to the king's wife, they in no way invest her with power to rule, or lead as a king. In 2 Melachim, chapters 9 and 10, we read that Jezebel was referred to as Gebirah, a term which connotes power, or Iron Lady; different from the term Giberet, a term which connotes a woman in a respectful manner. Gebirah is then the feminine equivalent of Gibor, a powerful man.
It was Jezebel who taught the people of Yisrael to commit adultery / idolatry and to abandon the laws of Kashrut; and Thyatira allowed the honor of Torah to be subsided.
This leads to the third error of Thyatira, allowing Jezebel to seduce the people astray. The Tosefta, in Sanhedrin 4:5, uses Jezebel as an example when commenting on the warning the Torah gives a king in not being wed to too many wives. The Torah, as the Tosefta says, is warning a king about wives, like Jezebel, who will seduce him into evil acts.
But how does Jezebel relate to the Shmita cycle? Jezebel appeared after the split between the northern Kingdom of Israel and the southern kingdom of Yehudah. It was during this time, after Ahab took the throne, that Eliyahu (Elijah) the prophet came to inform Ahab of a drought which would last 3½ years. Here, in Thyatira, Jezebel appears at the very split between the end of the first 3½ years and the beginning of the second 3½ years of the Shmita cycle.
In relation to the Nazareans, Jezebel was the force by which the Nazarean movement was being divided into two camps: those who were faithfully obedient which were outnumbered, and the majority which were the idolatrous. It is at this point in time the idolatrous ones were beginning to show their true color. Hakham Shaul spoke of them:
2
Thessalonians 2:3-11 Let no man
deceive you by any means: for [that day shall not come], except there come a
falling away first, and that man of transgression of Torah (sin)
be revealed, the son of perdition; 4. Who opposes and exalts himself above all
that is called HaShem, or that is worshipped; so that
he as HaShem sits in the temple of HaShem, showing
himself that he is HaShem. … 7. For the mystery of iniquity does already work:
only he who now lets [will let], until he be taken out of the way.
The author of the book of Revelation writes, in his masorah:
1 Yochanan 4:3
this
is that [spirit] of antichrist, whereof you have
heard that it should come; and even now already is it in the world.
The faithfully obedient of the
Nazareans were being divided and hunted in the days of the Roman
Emperor Constantine. What is even more, we see that this Jezebel, by being an
imposter, was the one which caused a split between the Nazareans and normative
Judaism.
The sins that the congregation of Thyatira committed are to undermine the Biblical leadership of the community, establish foreign ideals and non-Jewish rule.
Does not Thyatira share similar sins
to that of Pergamos? Could it possibly be related to the next festival, Yom Teruah? Here, some tradition must be
shared. The Rabbi's have stated that if it were not for the sin of the golden calf, and if the children of Israel
were truly receptive of the Torah, at Mount Sinai, on Shavuot, then the fall festivals would not have existed in the same way
they are now. In fact, the spring festivals would have
been emphasized more than the fall festivals; however, it works the other way
around today because of these errors. Thyatira rightly belongs to Yom Teruah. On Yom Teruah we make HaShem the King! What is our tikkun? We are
put on the balance scales. Do we make HaShem our King or some other thing our
ruler?
The Rosh
HaShana machzor (prayer book) divides the Musaf
(special service for the festival) service into three parts: Malchiyot, Zicranot, and Shofarot. On Yom Teruah we celebrate the crowning of
HaShem (Malchiyot)
and His Mashiach as our king. We recall how HaShem
remembered (Zicranot)
the mothers of the Tanach, to bring them children. There
can be no attachment to foreign gods while we stand in the presence of The
King. As at Shavuot, some have a custom of remaining
awake during the time of our judgment. During these hours we study Torah to
renew our attachment to HaShem. These
two items are the tikkun for the assemblies at Thyatira
which was involved in idolatry. How can one be involved with a
foreign god when he stands before the judge of the universe? We do these things with the power of the shofar. A shofar (Shofarot) comes from a clean animal which provides the
tikkun for the lack of kashrut experienced by the congregation at Thyatira.
As it appears, the main difference between Thyatira and Pergamos is that in Pergamos, there were those that followed Nicolaus, who in turn followed the way of Balaam (Balaq), i.e. to erect a stumbling block for the people of Yisrael. In Thyatira, however, Jezebel was meant to assimilate Jews into something else and to completely usurp them. What was going on in Thyatira, which indeed tales place today, seems more insidious. The Nicolaitans seemed more interested in defeating the Jews and getting rid of them rather than assimilating them like Jezebel. Both, none-the-less, discovered that the only way to defeat the Jewish people had to be done from the inside.
We
now come to the community at
Revelation
3:1-4 1 And unto the prophet of the community in Sardis
write; These things says he that has the seven Spirits
of HaShem, and the seven stars;
I know your works, that you have a name that you live, and are dead. 2 Be
watchful, and strengthen the things which remain, that are ready to die: for
I have not found your works perfect before HaShem. 3 Remember therefore how
you have received and heard, and hold fast, and repent. If therefore you shall
not watch, I will come on thee as a thief, and you shall not
know what hour I will come upon thee. 4 Thou hast a few names even in
So
what is the sin here? Initially it doesn’t appear there
is one, but close examination reveals a sin so prevalent that it is the main
topic of one of the Torah festivals, that sin being
egotism.
The
community of
Of
course, many people fall into the trap of believing that they are good enough, or even perfect, and then they turn on the
proverbial cruise-control of Torah observance and go on with their lives. This
should not be so, since this can later result in one leaving your first love, having found something or someone else out
their that captures your passion, when we should indeed continue to find new
ways of demonstrating our love for HaShem.
So which festival provides the cure for this cruise-control? Out of all the festivals, Yom HaKippurim is by far the most suited to this task. Many people see Yom HaKippurim as a day of turning from our sins, which is true, but the most important thing we repent of, on that day, is not the sins that we committed, but the mitzvot that we neglected!
On
Yom HaKippurim, a very prominent part of the service is the retelling of the Akeida, when Abraham took Isaac,
at HaShem’s command, to
It’s a powerful story, but one wonders about its relevance to Yom HaKippurim. Perhaps we remember that day and are to say to ourselves, “Thanks to Abraham, we can go to the Olam HaBa[19]”? Heaven forbid! When we say that, it implies that we only need to repent our evil deeds and then Abraham can do the heavy lifting and bring us into the Olam HaBa, when in fact the whole point of recalling the Akeida is to spur us to do enough mitzvot to be as worthy as Abraham was on that day. We are to say to ourselves, “Like Abraham, I will use all that is within me to show my love for HaShem, never ceasing in finding new ways to do so!”
An obvious connection for the community of
There
is more to this community of
Yom
HaKippurim is the time of our atonement. It is a
time for the mitzvot that effect the tikkun, the mitzvot where we deny the body any physical pleasure. We avoid all food and water for the entire day, as though we were
angels. We avoid bathing and anointing as though our bodies are already in
their proper state. We avoid the pleasures of sex,
the uniting with our spouse, in favor of uniting with The Holy One, blessed is
He! We do not wear leather shoes as they symbolize our bodies,
as they carry and support us through this world. We step out of our bodies, so
to speak. As we give up the physical pleasures which serve our lower self, we
begin to focus on our spiritual self and how to elevate ourselves beyond our
physical body, by focusing on our higher self. These things provide the tikkun
for the community at
Yom
HaKippurim thus presents a tikkun for the sin of the community at
There
is also another way of viewing the tikkun for the community at
Yeshayahu
(Isaiah) 56:7 Even them will I bring to my holy mountain, and make
them joyful in my house of prayer: their burnt offerings and their sacrifices shall be accepted
upon mine altar; for mine house shall be called an
house of prayer for all people.
Thus
when we bring Gentiles to the
Following
NO
OBVIOUS SIN
Revelation
3:7- 13 And to the prophet of the congregation
in Philadelphia write; These things says he that is holy, he that is true, he
that has the key of David, he that open, and no man shut; and shut, and no man
open; 8 I know your works: behold, I have set before thee an open door, and no
man can shut it: for you hast a little strength, and have kept my word, and
have not denied my name. 9 Behold,
I will make them of the synagogue of Satan, which
say they are Jews, and are not, but do lie; behold,
I will make them to come and worship before your feet,
and to know that I have loved you. 10 Because you have kept the word of
my patience, I also will keep you from the hour of temptation, which will come
upon all the world, to try them that dwell upon the
earth.
Succoth begins to
show us that we were able to achieve the atonement of Yom HaKippurim. As we
enter Succoth, we enter without sin. This connects us
with the assemblies at
Part of the process of Yom
HaKippurim is to reconcile the sins between brothers. We spend the entire
month of Elul going to our neighbors and seeking
forgiveness for the transgressions that we have committed. This reconciliation
of brothers is reflected in the meaning of the name
The wording of the comments to this
congregation also carry an allusion to the succah.
Revelation 3:8 I
have set before you an open door, and no man can shut it: for you have a little
strength, and have kept my word, and have not denied my authority.
We
understand that HaShem returns our good works to us
mida-keneged-mida, measure-for-measure. On Succoth,
we have a succah with an open door for visitors to come and enjoy good food and teaching. Our
hospitality is repaid by HaShem with open gates like those spoken of during the
prayer service for Yom HaKippurim.
Thus we see
Finally, we arrive at Shemini
Atzeret. On this festival we relax with HaShem,
basking in our relationship. This is an intense time when we enjoy and
appreciate our relationship with HaShem. This provides the tikkun for the congregation at
Revelation
3:14- 18 14 And unto the prophet if the congregation of the
Laodiceans write; These things says the Amen, the faithful and true witness,
the beginning of the creation of HaShem; 15 I know your works, that you are
neither cold nor hot: I would you were cold or hot. 16 So then because you are
lukewarm, and neither cold nor hot, I will spew you out of my mouth. 17 Because
you say, I am rich, and increased with goods, and have need of nothing; and
know not that you art wretched, and miserable, and poor, and blind, and naked:
18 I counsel you to buy of me gold tried in the fire,
that thou may be rich; and white raiment, that you may be clothed, and [that]
the shame of thy nakedness do not appear; and anoint your eyes
with eyesalve, that you may see.
The sin here is that of being lukewarm, neither hot nor cold,
but what does that mean exactly? What does it mean to be lukewarm? The passage
specifically says that HaShem looked at the Laodiceans’ works, their deeds.
Perhaps their deeds, or lack thereof, revealed their tepidness?
There
is proof in the Tanakh that this problem of tepidness is not a recent problem,
but is quite ancient:
Yehoshua
(Joshua) 24:15 and if wrong in your eyes to serve HaShem – choose
for you today whom you do serve; whether the gods whom your fathers served,
which are beyond the River, or the gods of the Amorite in whose land you are
dwelling; and I and my house – we serve HaShem.'
In describing Ahab[20], R. Yochanan states that Ahab had honor for the Torah and according to R. Nachman, Ahab was lukewarm. Though, Ahab committed idolatry by way of his wife Jezebel, he was generous with his money, and because he used to benefit scholars with his wealth, half [his sins] were forgiven. The Talmud first lists Ahab's idolatrous achievements; then it mentions his respect for Torah which was his good deed. R. Yochanan then states that Ahab has no portion in the World to Come because he wrote upon the gates of Samaria, “Ahab denies the HaShem of Israel.”
We also see another example of tepidness when Eliyahu ha Navi (Elijah the prophet) speaks to the people of Yisrael:
I Melachim
(Kings) 18:21 How long do you hold between two
opinions? if HaShem [be] HaShem, follow him: but if
Baal, [then] follow him. And the people answered him not a word.
Let’s
examine Shemini Atzeret and see what it is that we
do then, hopefully revealing more about this sin of tepidness.
On
Shemini Atzeret, we have an especially joyous time, dancing and singing whilst
holding the Torah scroll. On this day we end the
reading of the Torah and begin a new septennial cycle
with the hakhel, where the king of
It
seems that if we correlate our celebration with the sin stated here, the deeds
that reveal our tepidness are the ones related to our love of Torah. Our added pizzazz,
on Shemini Atzeret, would seem to be for the purposes of lighting our fire for HaShem’s word,
thereby repairing the problem of tepidness, replacing it with whole-hearted
passion.
Since
Shemini Atzeret is the 8th day of Succoth,
it also has a relationship to circumcision.
Circumcision is how one enters the covenant, and so
is also a day totally dedicated to studying the Torah which is central to being
part of the covenant. On this day we promise to embody the Torah just like
Abraham, Isaac, Jacob,
Moses, Aaron, David, Elijah, and Yeshua did. On this
day we dedicate ourselves to tabernacle in the flesh,
just as we see in the Nazarean Codicil:
Yochanan
(John)
Many Christian authors have attempted to correllate
the seven churches with seven epochs, or ages of the
Christian church.[21] They use various dates
for the epochs and various reasons for the epoch. This does not fit with the
Jewish character of the Book of Revelation. This section of Revelation is not
about Christian churches! This section is about Jewish communities.
To help us understand this concept, it is worth
noting that the earliest church (Greek - Ecclesia), in time, if found in second Luqas:
II Luqas (Acts) 7:37-38 This is that Moses, which said unto the children
of Israel, A prophet shall the Lord your God raise up unto you of your
brethren, like unto me; him shall ye hear. 38 This is he, that was in the church in the wilderness with the angel which spake to
him in the mount Sina, and our fathers: who received
the lively oracles to give unto us
Now, obviously there were no Christians in the church
in the wilderness with Moshe. This church was a congregation of Jews and a large mixed multitude of Gentiles. They were a congregation, a community, a
Jewish community. They all studied Torah and they were all involved in
fulfilling the mitzvot (Torah commandments).
Christian churches do not do these things.
Once we understand that these seven churches
were seven Jewish communities, it becomes obvious that the epochs assigned by
Christian authors are irrelavant because those epochs apply to epochs dealing
with Christianity, not those dealing with Jewish communities.
The arbitrary nature of the dates and the reasons
for the dates should alert us to the fact that something is wrong. If the
Christian authors had related them to the seven days of creation,
or the seven millenium that correspond with the
creation days, then we have something substantial, that is no longer arbitrary.
But, they do not do this. Instead they make up seven
artificial time periods dealing with the development of Christianity. Thus, we
can see that it is not reasonable to correlate the seven Jewish communities
with seven periods of Christian development.
The book of Revelation is dealing with revelations
which are applicable to Jews, to those who study and obey
the Torah. It is this group which will be able to discern the symbols and
the meaning behind the symbols.
Finally, our Sages teach us that every seven in the Torah is realted to every other seven found
in the Tanach and in the physical world. These realationships are not arbitrary, but are
given by HaShem to teach us about HaShem and His
ways. In this paper we have related the seven communities to the Sabbatical cycle and the seven festival
sabbaths. We have barely scratched the surface of this facinating subject.
There are many more connections to other sevens,
including the days of creation and the millenial days.
As you study, do not seek arbitrary epochs and do
not seek to relate this book to the Gentiles. Seek to relate these revelations
to the Jews and their communities. If you do this, then Mashiach
and Torah will truly be revealed.
* * *
So
now we have listed all the communities, their sins, and
the festivals used as treatments for the sins. Here
are some tables giving a brief index of what we've already learned.
|
FESTIVAL SABBATH (tikkun) |
ASSEMBLIES |
SIN |
|
|
Left first love |
|
|
|
Fear of Tribulations. |
|
|
Pergamos |
Doctrine of Balaam (Idolatry and fornication) |
|
|
Thyatira |
Idolatry and lack of kashrut
|
|
|
|
Egotism, physical life and spiritual death |
|
|
|
No obvious sin |
|
|
|
Lukewarm (rich and having no needs) |
|
Third Day |
Second Day |
First Day |
Shabbat |
Sixth Day |
Fifth Day |
Fourth Day |
|
Shavuot |
Pesach seventh day |
Pesach |
Shemini Atzeret |
Succoth |
Yom HaKippurim |
Yom Teruah |
|
Pergamos |
|
|
|
|
|
Thyatira |
|
Doctrine of Balaam (Idolatry and fornication) |
Tribulations |
Left first love |
Lukewarm (rich and having no needs) |
No obvious sin. |
Works show physical life and spiritual death |
Idolatry and lack of kashrut (two sins) |
|
|
Baptism in Yam Suf –
Born again |
|
|
Right after Yom HaKippurim |
|
|
|
COMMUNITIES |
Age (Kohelet Rabbah 1:2) |
|
|
At a year old he is like a king seated in a canopied
litter, fondled and kissed by all. |
|
|
At two and three he is like a pig, sticking his hands
in the gutters. |
|
Pergamos |
At ten he skips like a kid. |
|
Thyatira |
At twenty he is like a neighing horse, adorning his
person and longing for a wife. |
|
|
Having married, he is like an ass. |
|
|
When he has begotten children, he grows brazen like a
dog to supply their food and wants. |
|
|
When he has become old, he is [bent] like an ape. |
|
Communities |
Meaning[22] |
Sephirot |
Sin |
|
|
Permitted |
Chesed |
Left first love |
|
|
Myrrh |
Gevurah |
Fear of Tribulations. |
|
Pergamos |
Height or Elevation |
Teferet |
Doctrine of Balaam (Idolatry and fornication) |
|
Thyatira |
Odor of affliction |
Netzach |
Idolatry and lack of kashrut (two sins) |
|
|
Red ones |
Hod |
Works show physical life and spiritual death |
|
|
Brotherly love |
Yesod |
No obvious sin. |
|
|
Justice of the people |
Malkhut |
Lukewarm (rich and having no needs) |
|
Year 3 Rishon was given to the Levites and Priests And ani was given to the poor. rishon & ani |
Year 2 Rishon was given to the Levites and Priests Sheni was taken to rishon & sheni |
Year 1 Rishon was given to the Levites and Priests Sheni was taken to rishon & sheni |
Year 7 Sabbatical No tithe |
Year 6 Rishon was given to the Levites and Priests And ani was given to the poor. rishon & ani |
Year 5 Rishon was given to the Levites and Priests Sheni was taken to rishon & sheni |
Year 4 Rishon was given to the Levites and Priests Sheni was taken to rishon & sheni |
|
The ascent and descent |
The separation |
The birth |
The resurrection the
rebirth |
The honeymoon |
The return |
The King comes |
|
At ten he skips like a kid.[23] |
At two and three he is like a pig, sticking his hands in
the gutters. |
At a year old he is like a king seated in a canopied
litter, fondled and kissed by all. |
When he has become old, he is [bent] like an ape. |
When he has begotten children, he grows brazen like a dog
to supply their food and wants. |
Having married, he is like an ass. |
At twenty he is like a neighing horse, adorning his
person and longing for a wife. |
|
Pergamos Height or Elevation[24] |
Myrrh |
Permitted |
Justice of the
people |
Brotherly love |
Red ones |
Thyatira Odor of affliction |
|
Doctrine of Balaam (Idolatry and fornication) |
Fear of Tribulation |
Left first love |
Lukewarm (rich and having no needs) |
No obvious sin. |
Works show physical life and spiritual death |
Idolatry and lack of kashrut (two sins) |
|
Tiferet |
Gevurah |
Chesed |
Malkhut |
Yesod |
Hod |
Netzach |
* * *
This study was written by
Hillel ben David,
Micah ben Hillel,
Poriel ben Avraham
Comments may be submitted to:
Greg Killian
1101 Surrey Trace SE
Tumwater, WA 98501
Internet address: gkilli@aol.com
Web page: http://www.betemunah.org/
(360)
584-9352
Return to The WATCHMAN
home page
Send comments to Greg Killian
at his email address: gkilli@aol.com
[2] Cf. Ephesians 4:7-13
[3] For a good overview of Christian interpretation of the seven congregations in Rev. 1:1 – 3:22 please see: Mounce, Robert H., The Book of Revelation: The New International Commentary of the New Testament, Grand Rapids, Michigan: Eerdmans Publishing Co., 1977, pp. 83-85; as well as Ladd, George Eldon, A Commentary On The Revelation of John, Grand Rapids, Michigan: Eerdmans Publishing Co., 1972, pp. 10-14 .
[4] Cf. Genesis 1:28
[5] Leaven is an allusion to our Yetzer HaRa, our evil inclination.
[6] An acronym for Torah, Neviim, and Ketuvim (Law. Prophets, and Writings) – the so called Old Testament.
[7] Cf. John 14:15; 15:10.
[8] Cf. 1 Corinthians 5:8.
[9] Cf. 1 Corinthians 5:8
[10] Cf. Exodus 12:39.
[11] Gevurot HaShem (Ch. 36 &51)
[12] Cf. Pirke Abot 1:1
[13] For
the root meaning of this name see: Gerhard Kittel, Theological Dictionary of
the New Testament, Grand Rapids, Michigan: Eerdmans Publishing Co., 1967,
Vol. IV, pp. 942-945; and Joseph H. Thayer, Thayer’s Greek-English Lexicon
of the New Testament, Grand Rapids, Michigan: Baker Book House, 1977,
p.426, Entry: 3531.
[14] Melachim (kings) alef 18:4
[15] Melachim (kings) alef 18:4
[16] For
further information on this name see: Samuel Prideaux Tregelles, Gesenius’
Hebrew-Chaldee Lexicon to the Old Testament, Grand Rapids, Michigan: Baker
Book House, p.37, entry number 348.
[17] Wikipedia: Jezebel
[18] See the Orot Sephardic Yom Kippur Machzor, pager 825. The Midrash Rabbah on Bamidbar 2, compares Avraham to the son, Yitzchak to the moon, and Yaaqov to the stars.
[19] Olam HaBa – The coming world – Paradise.
[21] Cf. for example: John F. Walvoord, The Revelation of Jesus Christ, Chicago: Moody Press, 1966, pp. 11-78.
[22] From Strongs
[23] Kohelet Rabbah 1:2
[24] From Strongs